Norway says more aid needed to save Indonesian forest
Tuesday, 26 October 2010 18:47    PDF Print E-mail

(Reuters) - Indonesia could match Brazil's success in slowing  deforestation but needs far more aid from rich nations such as the United States, Japan and the European Union, Norway's environment minister said on Monday.

Norway has signed a $1 billion climate deal with Indonesia, under which Jakarta has agreed to impose a two-year ban on new permits to clear natural forests.

Norway has already released $30 million of the funds, with the bulk to be paid out later after Indonesia proves greenhouse gas emissions have gone down and an independent audit is done.

But more aid is needed to save Indonesia's forests, said Norwegian environment minister Erik Solheim.

"$1 billion is a huge amount of money but Indonesia needs quite substantially more to be able to conserve and sustainably manage its forests," Solheim told Reuters in an interview in Jakarta, where he is meeting Indonesian officials.

"The United States should come in, Japan, other European nations could come into this scheme to make it robust enough."

So far, Norway has been the biggest donor to protect tropical forests. At last year's Copenhagen climate summit, the United States, Australia, France, Japan, Britain and Norway agreed to provide a combined $3.5 billion from 2010-12 to help save forests.

Total pledges by rich donor nations rose to $4 billion in May, when members of a forest partnership met in Oslo.

Indonesia's vast tropical forests soak up enormous amounts of greenhouse gases but are threatened by agriculture and biofuel cultivation. Worldwide, deforestation is responsible for up to a fifth of all greenhouse gas emissions from human sources, according to U.N. data.

"The logic in the past was that you can make money from destroying the forest, you cannot make money from protecting the forest. That logic must be changed," said Solheim.

Oil-rich Norway has also allocated $250 million and $1 billion to forest conservation projects in Guyana and Brazil respectively.

"Brazil has reduced its deforestation rate by 80 percent from 2003 until 2010. That's a fantastic result. I think the prospects for Indonesia are of the same magnitude," he said.

Solheim said it was up to Indonesia, not Norway, to define which forests would be saved under the moratorium or whether existing permits to clear valuable forest would be honored.

"If Indonesia came to Norway to tell us how to do our oil and gas production, Norwegians would laugh," he said.

Palm oil firms such as Wilmar, SMART and Indofood Agri Resources have big expansion plans and vast land banks in Indonesia, the world's biggest producer of the oil used in cosmetics, ice cream and other products.

While Indonesian officials have said they would prefer for the $1 billion to be handled by an internationally reputable Indonesian institution, Solheim said Norway preferred an international institution such as the World Bank.

"This is a matter we have to discuss with the government of Indonesia," he said.

MARKET-BASED OFFSETS DISTANT

Part of Norway's donation will be used to set aside forests for pilot projects under a planned U.N-backed forest carbon offset scheme, called reduced emissions from deforestation and degradation (REDD).

So far, most REDD pilot projects are funded by governments. A market-based REDD scheme -- under which rich polluters could offset their emissions by paying poor countries not to chop down their trees -- was a distant prospect, Solheim said.

"That may come in 10 years time or so. It's much more likely we will get a market-based system in other areas such as energy," he said. "Some who are arguing that it should not be market-based can sleep peacefully because we are very far from a market-based system. Every single cent will come from taxpayers." (By Sunanda Creagh; Editing by Alister Doyle and Andrew Marshall)

Source: Reuters

Comments (0)

Subscribe to this comment's feed

Write comment

smaller | bigger
security image
Write the displayed characters

busy
 

Document

Documentation to facilitate negotiations among Parties. Note by the Chair. Addendum. Land use, land-use change and forestry.

Documentation to facilitate negotiations among Parties. Note by the Chair. Addendum. Land use, land-use change and forestry.AbstractThis addendum is a draft decision text on options and proposals on how to ... + READ MORE

Financial governance and Indonesia’s Reforestation Fund during the Soeharto and post-Soeharto periods, 1989–2009: a political economic analysis of lessons for REDD+

This study analyses Indonesia’s experience with its Reforestation Fund, and examines implications for REDD+. The Reforestation Fund (Dana Reboisasi, DR) is a national forest fund financed by a volume-based timber levy to support ... + READ MORE

Draft decision -/CMP.5: Proposal by the President. Copenhagen Accord.

Draft decision -/CMP.5: Proposal by the President. Copenhagen Accord.NotesAgenda item 15High-level segmentDocument codeFCCC/KP/CMP/2009/L.9Publication date18 December 2009Source: ... + READ MORE

Draft decision -/CP.15: Proposal by the President. Copenhagen Accord.

Draft decision -/CP.15: Proposal by the President. Copenhagen Accord.NotesAgenda item 9High-level segmentDocument codeFCCC/CP/2009/L.7Publication date18 December 2009Source: ... + READ MORE

Draft decision -/CMP.5: Outcome of the work of the Ad Hoc Working Group on Further Commitments for Annex I Parties under the Kyoto Protocol. Proposal by the President.

Draft decision -/CMP.5: Outcome of the work of the Ad Hoc Working Group on Further Commitments for Annex I Parties under the Kyoto Protocol. Proposal by the President.NotesAgenda item 15High-level ... + READ MORE

More in: Analysis, Data & information, UNFCCC negotiation, Statement & announcement

Forest & REDD

New global carbon map for 2.5 billion ha of forests

News image

2.5-billion-ha carbon map shows forests store 250B tons of carbon Forest carbon stock Tropical forests across Latin America, Africa, and Southeast Asia stored 247 gigatons of carbon — more than 30 years' worth of current emissions ... + READ MORE

Is Indonesia’s Program to Stop Deforestation in Meltdown?

News image

Back in December, I wrote an article for Mother Jones about Indonesia's efforts to reduce its levels of deforestation and, by extension, its greenhouse gas emissions, which are the third highest in the world, trailing ... + READ MORE

More Than 20 Years of Forest Carbon Yield Plenty of Lessons for Investors

It's more than two decades since a handful of environmental non-profits and green industrialists first began experimenting with mechanisms that slow global warming by funding the preservation of rainforests.  In the ensuing decades, we've ... + READ MORE

Palm oil giant vows to spare most valuable Indonesian rainforest

News image

Golden Agri-Resources – the world's second highest palm oil producer – bows to pressure from the west The world's second biggest palm oil company has agreed to halt deforestation in valuable areas of Indonesian forest, bowing to pressure ... + READ MORE

Prince Charles: 'direct relationship' between ecosystems and the economy

News image

At an EU meeting in Brussels, dubbed the Low Carbon Prosperity Summit, the UK's Prince Charles made the case that without healthy ecosystems, the global economy will suffer. "We have to see that there ... + READ MORE

More in: Forest & REDD

Climate Change

Poor will pay the price to cut carbon emissions

News image

While Australians grapple with the idea of putting a price on carbon, in many developing countries the choice looks more like a trade-off between national development out of poverty a... + READ MORE

World off course on climate; renewables vital

News image

(Reuters) - The world is off course in fighting climate change and governments need to boost green energies to build new momentum, the head of the U.N. panel of climate ... + READ MORE

Non-Aligned Movement vital to battle against climate change, Ban says

News image

Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon today called on the Non-Aligned Movement (NAM) of more than 100 countries to assist in “urgent global action” to combat the threat posed by climate change. ... + READ MORE

Nauru will use UN spotlight to confront developed world over climate change

News image

The smallest nation in the UN is about to take the AOSIS chair at a time when low-lying coastal countries are gravely threatened Last month I returned to Nauru, ... + READ MORE

Japan wants new CO2 offset scheme to complement U.N.

News image

(Reuters) - Japan's idea for a new carbon offset scheme would complement an existing U.N. mechanism and make it easier for developing countries to access ... + READ MORE

More in: Climate Change