Climate Change
Climate solutions: Local nuance at the heart of climate policies
Wednesday, 01 September 2010 10:29    PDF Print E-mail

In his Independence Day speech, President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono announced the results of the latest population census, sparking concern as to how the country was handling the looming challenge of a population boom.

According to the Central Statistics Agency (BPS), Indonesia is now home to 237.6 million people, an increase of about 32.5 million since 2000. Within the next five years, Indonesia’s population will grow to 250 million, according to estimates.

In the context of climate change, this may well lead to a dramatic growth in consumption and other human-induced activities, which could significantly increase greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions as by-products of economic growth.

As we may learn, an increase in GHG emissions correlates with an increase in the concentration of GHG in the atmosphere, resulting in climate change and its associated impacts — which will eventually affect Indonesians.

Even without climate change, the exponential growth rate of the country’s population has contributed to continuous pressures on remaining natural resources and ecosystems.

Climate change may worsen existing environmental degradation resulting from illegal and destructive logging, forest conversion, overfishing and over exploitation of natural resources.

Because this massive archipelagic nation has adopted a decentralized system, local governments and people must shoulder the burden of this issue.

One of the country’s biggest challenges right now is to formulate climate policies and initiate programs that seriously reflect local aspirations and incorporate ongoing efforts at the local level.

A number of climate policies developed since 2007 mostly focus on strategic intervention to reduce GHG emissions by 26 percent by 2020 at the national level, or prioritize action in key development sectors.

This approach, however, leaves a substantial gap when it comes to action on the ground. Comparing polices at the national level, or in key development sectors, with intervention at a local level, has never been easy. Decentralization in Indonesia is a highly complex subject.

Many experts have praised Indonesia’s decentralization and transformation but concerns over the division of authorities and fiscal distribution remain.

For instance, policies formulated and actions taken by national government (in all sectors) often differ or clash with those taken at the provincial or district level.

This is also true in the case of climate change.

According to Dr. Meine van Noordwijk of the World Agroforestry Centre (ICRAF), how reductions of GHG emissions are likely to be allocated over sectors and, more importantly, over parts of the country, has not been decided yet.

Provinces and districts in Sumatra, Kalimantan and Papua, for instance, are still drafting their low-carbon development plans.

In these drafts, provinces and districts have voiced their aspirations to address climate change and sustainability.

In a decentralized model, it is crucial that the already developed and currently formulated national and sectoral climate change policies take into account these sub-national or local policy aspirations.

If the figures from different layers of the government do not match, it will be a Herculean task for the country to commit to pledge to reduce GHG emissions.

Kuntoro Mangkusubroto, head of the Indonesian team negotiating the bilateral agreement with Norway to reduce carbon emissions, recently said the Indonesian government had acknowledged the need for a system with high integrity, which left no room for leakages, to implement REDD+ successfully.

He explained a high degree of integrity was fundamental since compensation for REDD+ implementation would depend on the credibility of this system.

Setting up positive incentives, including financial ones, is another way to encourage local governments and actors to be more involved in climate change mitigation.

This is important since benefits resulting from any climate change policies need to be felt and distributed in an equitable manner.

Moreover, these incentives need to be framed by rules that ensure benefits created flow to, and are retained by, local and indigenous people — as well as poor communities — who are among the most resource-dependent people and providers of important environmental services.

In the past, the position, rights and interests of local and indigenous people were often overlooked or marginalized when the government formulated environmental policies.

As a result, poverty and environmental degradation are still prevalent.

Including local and indigenous people is therefore key to instituting better climate governance.

The recipient of the 2009 Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences, Elinor Ostrom, said social arrangements were crucial in determining the outcomes of policies, particularly when these were aimed at influencing human behavior interconnecting with economic matters.

In the Indonesian context, understanding the complexity of decentralization, taking into account aspirations of local governments and people, can be viewed as appropriate social arrangements.

This is not only likely to ensure successful outcomes from climate policies, but could also help minimize the cost of implementation of these policies, reduce social conflicts and provide social insurance in case of hazards.

Most importantly, this would strengthen the confidence and trust among all stakeholders and right holders — which is crucial for the nation itself. (By Fitrian Ardiansyah)

The writer is a PhD candidate at the Australian National University, a recipient of the Australian Leadership Award and Allison Sudradjat Award, as well as an advisor to WWF-Indonesia on climate and energy. He can be reached at This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it

Source: The Jakarta Post

Some rights for the image is reserved under Creative Commons license

Last Updated ( Tuesday, 07 September 2010 09:59 )
 
China eyes local carbon trade, CDM priority for now
Friday, 13 August 2010 12:10    PDF Print E-mail

(Reuters) - China's plans to launch a series of pilot carbon trading projects starting next year underscores its need to curb its soaring greenhouse gas emissions -- now believed to be the world's largest.

With power capacity set to double again in the next decade to 1,600 gigawatts, far more than the United States, billions of dollars of investment in cleaner technologies will be needed, and a carbon price would help increase energy efficiency without jeopardising breakneck economic growth.

It could also be a boon to some domestic environmental exchanges if a compulsory national trading scheme is launched.

But experts say China, the world's second-largest energy consumer, won't be rushing to launch a national emissions trading scheme or to commit to absolute emissions reduction targets.

"The big picture will be worked out before March, but I believe there are going to be certain components that need more time to be worked out -- the details on how to implement it will take some time," said Changhua Wu, China director at the London-based Climate Group.

In the short term, China will want to protect its position in a U.N.-backed global carbon trading scheme that has earned it billions of dollars from rich nations in exchange for carbon offsets, known as certified emission reductions (CERs).

Beijing will also be cautious given that global climate talks on a "scaled-up" version of the Clean Development Mechanism (CDM), capable of delivering even more investment, have largely stalled.

EXPERT PANEL

A researcher at the National Development and Reform Commission told Reuters that an expert panel has been working for more than a year on pilot carbon trading schemes in high-emission provinces or sectors -- but dramatic gestures are unlikely.

"Nothing is decided yet and China is still looking to see what happens to the CDM and the global climate talks," said the researcher, who did not want to give his name because he was not authorised to speak to the media.

The NDRC confirmed on Tuesday this week it was looking into the possibility of using "market mechanisms" in a number of pilot low-carbon cities and regions.

A broad commitment to carbon trading will be included in China's 2011-2015 five-year plan, to be ratified by parliament in March 2011, but the full details are unlikely to emerge immediately, said Wu of The Climate Group, who has been involved in the consultations.

The cornerstone of any Chinese carbon market will be the country's pledge, made last year, to reduce its 2005 carbon intensity rate -- the amount of CO2 produced per unit of GDP -- by 40-45 percent before the end of 2020.

The China Daily newspaper said in July that officials had "reached a consensus" that CO2 trading would be a necessary component.

ZhongXiang Zhang, a carbon expert at the East West Center in Hawaii, said China's intensity targets would eventually be "converted to absolute emission caps at company levels" and that this would form the basis for a domestic trading platform.

PROTECTING THE CDM

The CDM, part of the United Nations' Kyoto Protocol, grants CERs to industrialised nations when they invest in clean-energy projects in the developing world. Those CERs are traded or used to comply with Kyoto targets.

While it remains unclear what the CDM will look like after 2012 when the Kyoto Protocol's first phase expires, its future direction is expected to shape China's own carbon market plans.

China has supported calls for a "scaling-up" of the old project-based CDM but it has also expressed opposition to reforms proposed by Europe that would commit entire sectors, rather than single projects, to reducing CO2.

While domestic sectoral targets are on its agenda, Beijing has complained that introducing such methods to the post-Kyoto CDM amounts to a "mandatory" cut and thus violates the Kyoto principle of "common but differentiated responsibilities". This says rich nations should bear most of the burden of cutting CO2.

China's concerns are practical as well as ideological. If a company already has to meet CO2 targets at home, it might find itself in violation of a key concept known as "additionality": if its carbon reduction plans would have gone ahead anyway, it is not entitled to "additional" CDM revenue through issuing of CERs.

Zhang of the East-West Center said China will make sure that any local market it sets up will remain strictly domestic and unconnected from the CDM or any of its potential replacements.

If the EU gets its way on CDM reform, it could complicate China's plans to cap sectoral emissions or force a level of market integration that it is not prepared to accept, Zhang said.

A FEW PIONEERS

Whatever happens to the CDM, China's 20 or so environmental exchanges are hoping government commitments to reduce CO2 will boost their own voluntary trading schemes and eventually put them at the centre of a single global market.

So far, Chinese voluntary emissions trading has remained negligible, with no compelling reasons to participate.

"I think they have explored all options and tried their best but the regulatory system is the major problem -- you cannot rely on a few pioneers," said Allan Zhang, director of sustainable business solutions at PriceWaterhouseCoopers in Beijing.

A compulsory, not piecemeal, scheme was also crucial.

The China Beijing Environmental Exchange (CBEEX) could benefit most if firms were forced to buy CO2 credits. Its general manager, Mei Dewen, said it was now a matter of preparation.

Mandatory "cap and trade" schemes might still be some way away, but the issue of pre-compliance -- buying carbon credits now in order to meet binding targets imposed in the future -- could still drive domestic buyers, he said.

"Cap and trade is the Ferrari," Mei told Reuters in June. "We are now just driving a tractor, but things could change -- if you can't drive the tractor then you won't be able to drive the Ferrari."

($1 = 6.778 Yuan)

(By David Stanway; Editing by David Fogarty)

Source: Reuters

Some rights for the image is reserved under Creative Commons license

 
Bonn climate talks disappointing: RI
Tuesday, 10 August 2010 11:38    PDF Print E-mail

Indonesia voiced concern over the outcome of climate change talks in Bonn, Germany, which seemed to move the world further away from a global treaty on emissions cuts targets in Cancun, Mexico, this year.

The five-day climate negotiation, part of the second round of talks before the Cancun summit, was concluded over the weekend (Saturday in Jakarta).

"We are unhappy with the results *of the Bonn meeting*," Indonesian delegation head Rachmat Witoelar told The Jakarta Post from Germany on Sunday.

"This is like a patient suffering a severe disease but not able to die."

He said a lot of work remained undone before the upcoming meeting in China, the last preparatory meeting ahead of Cancun.

The Bonn meeting was the third round of talks this year after the failure of the Copenhagen summit to reach a legally binding treaty.

Around 110 heads of state and governments from the world attended the Copenhagen summit last year.

Rachmat did not elaborate the result of the Bonn meeting, saying it was difficult to repeat the successes made in Bali in 2007.

The Bali meeting reached a consensus after a fortnight of tough negotiations to agree on the Bali road map and Bali action plan. The road map set the deadline for the world to adopt a legally binding treaty in 2009.

The Copenhagen summit, however, failed to meet the target, ending in the Copenhagen Accord political statement.

"It is now difficult to replicate the outcomes of the Bali meeting because a number of developing countries, including Indonesia, have developed rapidly," he said.

"Categorizing annex and non-annex *countries* should be seen in the context of what we can do for the planet, and not what the planet can do for us."

Under the existing Kyoto protocol, only rich "annex" countries are legally bound to cut their emissions.

The undeveloped and developing "non-annex" countries, including emerging countries Indonesia, China, India and Brazil, requested funding from rich nations to mitigate and adapt to the severe impacts of climate change.

Developed nations, however, argued that the emerging countries should also adhere to legally binding targets.

Rachmat said the likely outcome of the Cancun meeting would be a new time line to agree on a global treaty.

US deputy special envoy Jonathan Pershing also expressed disappointment over the poor progress made at the Bonn meeting.

"I came to Bonn hopeful of a deal in Cancun, but at this point I am very concerned as I have seen some countries walking back from progress made in Copenhagen," Jonathan said as quoted by Reuters.

The European Union's co-lead negotiator, Artur Runge-Metzger, also accused some countries of adding text in a "tit for tat" way and said, "It is important in Tianjin to turn that spirit around."

The Worldwide Fund for Nature (WWF) warned the upcoming meeting in Tianjin, China, should be the last opportunity for governments to resolve outstanding issues and agree to address climate change.

"It was worrying to see that the discussions in Bonn that moved behind closed doors did not progress issues adequately. The mitigation discussion even went backwards and became more polarized," Gordon Shepherd, leader of the WWF global climate change initiative said in a statement. (By Adianto P. Simamora)

Source: The Jakarta Post

 
Officials point to Russian drought and Asian deluge as consistent with climate change
Tuesday, 10 August 2010 11:35    PDF Print E-mail

Government officials are pointing to the drought and wildfires in Russia, and the floods across Central and East Asia as consistent with climate change predictions. While climatologists say that a single weather event cannot be linked directly to a warming planet, patterns of worsening storms, severer droughts, and disasters brought on by extreme weather are expected as the planet warms.

Russia burning

In Russia, likely thousands of people have died from heat-related illnesses and 20 percent of the nation's grain harvest has been lost due to a prolonged drought, record-breaking high temperatures, and hundreds of peatland and forest fires, which have blanketed Moscow in a toxic fog. This summer Moscow has broken 100 degrees Fahrenheit a number of times, while the previous record was 99 degrees Fahrenheit.

Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin has put a ban on grain exports from Russian in order to keep prices low domestically until 2011. Putin's announcement aggravated fears of a global food crisis as wheat prices have almost doubled since June.

On Thursday, Russian President Dmitry Medvedev told a Russian Security Council meeting, "Everyone is talking about climate change now. Unfortunately, what is happening now in our central regions is evidence of this global climate change, because we have never in our history faced such weather conditions in the past. This means that we need to change the way we work, change the methods that we used in the past."

On Friday Medvedev continued his sudden frankness on climate change, warning that climate change could impact the Winter Olympics.

"Frankly, what is going on with the world’s climate at the moment should incite us all (I mean world leaders and heads of public organizations) to make a more strenuous effort to fight global climate change," he said. Russia is one of the world's largest greenhouse gas emitters: when emissions due to deforestation are not included, Russia is listed as among the top 4, after China and the US, and nearly equal to India.

Prior to the heat-disaster in Russia, Medvedev announced that the nation aimed to 'cut' greenhouse gas emissions by 10-15 percent by 2020, however since this is based on a baseline of 1990 emissions (before the Soviet Union collapsed), it would actually allow Russia's greenhouse gas emissions to rise by 29-36 percent over the next ten years, according to Reuters.

The Asian Deluge

At the same time as central Russia is experiencing record heat and debilitating fires, a number of Asian nations have been hit with catastrophic flooding and mud slides. Flashfloods in India have left 132 people dead and some 500 missing, while mudslides in China due to flooding has taken the lives of 127 people. Nearly 50,000 people have been evacuated in China.

But to date no nation appears worst hit than Pakistan, where flooding has killed 1,600 people and affected 14 million. Landslides have followed the flooding killing dozens more.

Rice crops have also been impacted, furthering concerns of an impending global food crisis. Currently it is estimated that 4 million Pakistani flood victims are in need of food. The floods are being considered the worse in 80 years.

Pakistani glaciologist, Prof M. Iqbal Khan, told the Associated Press of Pakistan that the flooding was linked to melting glaciers in upper Pakistan.

"I have warned everyone about the floods in Peshawar, Charsadda and Nowshera due to the global warming in my previous interviews but nobody took notice and the result is before us," he said, adding that "it is the glaciers which are adding fuel to the fire and due to the melting of glaciers the flood situation is aggravated."

Experts say a warming world increases the likelihood and severity of flooding in some regions since warmer temperatures causes increases the volume of water vapor in the air leading to heavier precipitation events.

More water vapor also feeds severe storms, boosting their strength and severity. Asia has not been alone in experiencing unusually severe flooding. A number of record floods also hit the United States over the last six months.

Progress slow on climate change negotiations

Meanwhile a climate conference in Bonn, Germany, ended on Friday with what looked like little progress on increasingly difficult negotiations. US chief negotiator Jonathan Pershing said that both the fires in Russia and the floods in Pakistan were "consistent with the kind of changes we could expect from climate change, and they will get worse if we don't act quickly".

Wendel Trio, climate policy director from Greenpeace, said more starkly: ''Russia is burning and Pakistan is drowning, yet [officials] seem happy to continue as if they have all the time in the world."

The last six months have been the hottest on record worldwide since data-taking began in the late 19th Century. The decade from 2000-2009 was also the warmest on record. Climate experts overwhelmingly say that the world is warming due to extensive greenhouse gas emissions from human activities. (By Jeremy Hance)

Source: Mongabay

Some rights for the image is reserved under Creative Commons license

 
Int’l donors allot $87m grant for environmental projects
Tuesday, 10 August 2010 11:32    PDF Print E-mail

The world’s leading financier for environmental projects, the Global Environment Facility (GEF), has allotted a US$87 million grant to help Indonesia protect its dwindling environmental assets, officials say.

Environment Minister Gusti Muhammad Hatta said that about half of the money would be awarded to projects dealing with mitigation and adaptation to prevent climate change.

“The project developers could be from the government, local communities, NGOs or universities,” he told reporters Monday.

The $87 million grant will be disbursed based on projects approved by the GEF executive board in Washington during the from Aug. 1, 2010, to July 31, 2014.

Indonesia received a $40 million grant from the GEF for the previous four-year period.

The GEF is an independent financial organization that awards grants to developing countries to finance projects linked to climate change, biodiversity, land degradation, ozone layer and persistent organic pollutants issues.

The GEF was set up in 1991 with the World Bank serves as its trustee.

The GEF has allocated $8.8 billion for more than 2,400 projects in more than 165 developing countries and countries whose economies are in transition.

GEF’s presence in Indonesia is currently chaired by Environment Ministry secretary-general Arief Yuwono.

The GEF Indonesia secretariat, which consists of several senior government officials would assess all proposals before submitting them to the GEF’s headquarters in Washington for approval.

Division head for multilateral cooperation at GEF’s Indonesia secretariat, Wahyu Marjaka, said that as of Monday, 23 project proposals had been submitted.

“We are still evaluating a proposal to build a water-based electrical power [facility] in Wakatobi, Southeast Sulawesi. We target to propose at least 10 project proposals to GEF Washington before November,” he said.

He said the Wakatobi project would supply free electricity to at least five villages in the area.

Wahyu said the grant from the GEF would also be used to support the government’s commitment to cut emissions by 26 percent by 2020.

The government has pledged to cut the country’s emissions by 26 percent using Rp 83 trillion of state money. If rich nations provide Rp 168 trillion in additional financial assistance, Indonesia would further cut its emissions by another 15 percent by 2020.

However, the government has not finished formulating its plan to meet the targets.

A number of countries have also pledged to provide money to Indonesia to reduce emissions, particularly from the forestry sector.

Indonesia and Norway signed a climate deal worth $1 billion to reduce Indonesia’s deforestation rate to reduce emissions. Indonesia has received an additional $106.6 million to preserve its forests.

Australia has said it plans to invest $70 million for carbon financing projects in Central Kalimantan and Jambi while Germany has promised $26 million for REDD pilot projects in Kapuas Hulu in West Kalimantan and Berau in East Kalimantan.

South Korea has pledged $5 million to develop a REDD project for forests in West Nusa Tenggara and last week the United Nations-REDD pledged $5.6 million for a REDD project in Central Sulawesi. (By Adianto P. Simamora)

Source: The Jakarta Post

Some rights for the image is reserved under Creative Commons license

Last Updated ( Friday, 13 August 2010 10:32 )
 


Page 11 of 86

Document

Documentation to facilitate negotiations among Parties. Note by the Chair. Addendum. Land use, land-use change and forestry.

Documentation to facilitate negotiations among Parties. Note by the Chair. Addendum. Land use, land-use change and forestry.AbstractThis addendum is a draft decision text on options and proposals on how to ... + READ MORE

Financial governance and Indonesia’s Reforestation Fund during the Soeharto and post-Soeharto periods, 1989–2009: a political economic analysis of lessons for REDD+

This study analyses Indonesia’s experience with its Reforestation Fund, and examines implications for REDD+. The Reforestation Fund (Dana Reboisasi, DR) is a national forest fund financed by a volume-based timber levy to support ... + READ MORE

Draft decision -/CMP.5: Proposal by the President. Copenhagen Accord.

Draft decision -/CMP.5: Proposal by the President. Copenhagen Accord.NotesAgenda item 15High-level segmentDocument codeFCCC/KP/CMP/2009/L.9Publication date18 December 2009Source: ... + READ MORE

Draft decision -/CP.15: Proposal by the President. Copenhagen Accord.

Draft decision -/CP.15: Proposal by the President. Copenhagen Accord.NotesAgenda item 9High-level segmentDocument codeFCCC/CP/2009/L.7Publication date18 December 2009Source: ... + READ MORE

Draft decision -/CMP.5: Outcome of the work of the Ad Hoc Working Group on Further Commitments for Annex I Parties under the Kyoto Protocol. Proposal by the President.

Draft decision -/CMP.5: Outcome of the work of the Ad Hoc Working Group on Further Commitments for Annex I Parties under the Kyoto Protocol. Proposal by the President.NotesAgenda item 15High-level ... + READ MORE

More in: Analysis, Data & information, UNFCCC negotiation, Statement & announcement

Forest & REDD

New global carbon map for 2.5 billion ha of forests

News image

2.5-billion-ha carbon map shows forests store 250B tons of carbon Forest carbon stock Tropical forests across Latin America, Africa, and Southeast Asia stored 247 gigatons of carbon — more than 30 years' worth of current emissions ... + READ MORE

Is Indonesia’s Program to Stop Deforestation in Meltdown?

News image

Back in December, I wrote an article for Mother Jones about Indonesia's efforts to reduce its levels of deforestation and, by extension, its greenhouse gas emissions, which are the third highest in the world, trailing ... + READ MORE

More Than 20 Years of Forest Carbon Yield Plenty of Lessons for Investors

It's more than two decades since a handful of environmental non-profits and green industrialists first began experimenting with mechanisms that slow global warming by funding the preservation of rainforests.  In the ensuing decades, we've ... + READ MORE

Palm oil giant vows to spare most valuable Indonesian rainforest

News image

Golden Agri-Resources – the world's second highest palm oil producer – bows to pressure from the west The world's second biggest palm oil company has agreed to halt deforestation in valuable areas of Indonesian forest, bowing to pressure ... + READ MORE

Prince Charles: 'direct relationship' between ecosystems and the economy

News image

At an EU meeting in Brussels, dubbed the Low Carbon Prosperity Summit, the UK's Prince Charles made the case that without healthy ecosystems, the global economy will suffer. "We have to see that there ... + READ MORE

More in: Forest & REDD

Climate Change

Poor will pay the price to cut carbon emissions

News image

While Australians grapple with the idea of putting a price on carbon, in many developing countries the choice looks more like a trade-off between national development out of poverty a... + READ MORE

World off course on climate; renewables vital

News image

(Reuters) - The world is off course in fighting climate change and governments need to boost green energies to build new momentum, the head of the U.N. panel of climate ... + READ MORE

Non-Aligned Movement vital to battle against climate change, Ban says

News image

Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon today called on the Non-Aligned Movement (NAM) of more than 100 countries to assist in “urgent global action” to combat the threat posed by climate change. ... + READ MORE

Nauru will use UN spotlight to confront developed world over climate change

News image

The smallest nation in the UN is about to take the AOSIS chair at a time when low-lying coastal countries are gravely threatened Last month I returned to Nauru, ... + READ MORE

Japan wants new CO2 offset scheme to complement U.N.

News image

(Reuters) - Japan's idea for a new carbon offset scheme would complement an existing U.N. mechanism and make it easier for developing countries to access ... + READ MORE

More in: Climate Change